Real Skill packageSource verifiedClawHub registry

ars-academic-reviewer

Multi-perspective academic paper review with dynamic reviewer personas. Runs a 5-seat, role-separated review panel (Journal-Fit Reviewer + 3 peer-review roles + Devil's Advocate) with field-specific expertise; role separation is not a claim of independent error processes. Supports full review, re-review (verification), quick assessment, methodology focus, Socratic guided, and calibration modes. Triggers on: review paper, peer review, manuscript review, referee report, review my paper, critique paper, simulate revi…

Identity and source

Publisher attributionsedey999registry owner unverified by skillvetai
Functional categorySearch, Research & Knowledgeautomatically inferred · 58% rule confidence
Package forminstruction bundle99 recorded files
Canonical sourceClawHub registryclawhub:sedey999:ars-academic-reviewer
Open canonical source ↗

Platform declarations

These states come from the source or distribution context. None of the entries below are SkillVetAI compatibility test results.

OpenClawnative officialProvenance: registry distribution

Independent structural checks

These checks parse the fixed package against dated platform rules. They do not execute the Skill or verify task behavior.

Claude Codepasses structure
Checker 0.1.0 · agent-skills-2026-08-13+claude-code-docs-2026-08-13 · 8/22/2026.claude/skills/ars-academic-reviewer

Runtime, accounts, dependencies, permissions, network behavior and task quality remain untested.

OpenAI Codexpasses structure
Checker 0.1.0 · agent-skills-2026-08-13+codex-docs-2026-08-13 · 8/22/2026.agents/skills/ars-academic-reviewer

Runtime, accounts, dependencies, permissions, network behavior and task quality remain untested.

OpenClawpasses structure
Checker 0.1.0 · agent-skills-2026-08-13+openclaw-docs-2026-08-13 · 8/22/2026skills/ars-academic-reviewer

Runtime, accounts, dependencies, permissions, network behavior and task quality remain untested.

Installation and inspection

This command is recorded from the source ecosystem and resolves the registry's latest release. The fixed release shown on this page should be inspected before adoption.

clawhub install @sedey999/ars-academic-reviewer
clawhub inspect @sedey999/ars-academic-reviewer --version 1.11.2

Security evidence

SkillVetAI static result: medium signal

This automated, non-executing scan is bound to this release hash. It is not a safety certification and may contain false positives or false negatives.

Status
completed
Coverage
partial text content
Files
40 / 99 inspected as text
Checked
8/22/2026, 1:06:23 PM
Scanner
0.1.3
Policy
1.0.3
6 automated findings
mediumPrompt-override language requires reviewreferences/devils_advocate_reviewer_agent.md:109 · confidence 62%ignore prior instructions
mediumPrompt-override language requires reviewreferences/domain_reviewer_agent.md:108 · confidence 62%ignore prior instructions
mediumPrompt-override language requires reviewreferences/eic_agent.md:107 · confidence 62%ignore prior instructions
mediumPrompt-override language requires reviewreferences/guides/reviewer_sprint_prompt_source.md:115 · confidence 62%ignore prior instructions
mediumPrompt-override language requires reviewreferences/methodology_reviewer_agent.md:104 · confidence 62%ignore previous instructions
mediumPrompt-override language requires reviewreferences/perspective_reviewer_agent.md:108 · confidence 62%ignore prior instructions
2 inferred permission indicators
  • network access — automatically inferred
  • filesystem write — automatically inferred
3 dependency and API indicators
  • api: doi.org
  • api: github.com
  • api: json-schema.org
External clawhub result: clean

This is registry-supplied evidence for the recorded release, not an independent SkillVetAI scan. Check the canonical source for the full report, scanner versions, scope, and current moderation state.

Evidence checked
8/22/2026, 12:15:38 PM
Release binding
Matches this record
  • vt: clean
  • skillspector: suspicious
  • llm: clean

Recorded files

The catalog stores hashes and an inventory summary for change detection. It does not republish the package contents.

Package content hashsha256:0562ff29c4ee1e4d8d4415d9b5153b0956457b56a345d0cf927e7ab350211baa
Show up to 30 recorded paths
  • ATTRIBUTION.md
  • LICENSE
  • README.md
  • references/devils_advocate_reviewer_agent.md
  • references/domain_reviewer_agent.md
  • references/editorial_synthesizer_agent.md
  • references/eic_agent.md
  • references/examples/hei_paper_review_example.md
  • references/examples/interdisciplinary_review_example.md
  • references/examples/passport_with_experiment_provenance.yaml
  • references/examples/subclaim_decomposition_example.md
  • references/field_analyst_agent.md
  • references/guides/calibration_mode_protocol.md
  • references/guides/editorial_decision_standards.md
  • references/guides/guided_mode_protocol.md
  • references/guides/integration_guide.md
  • references/guides/quality_rubrics.md
  • references/guides/re_review_mode_protocol.md
  • references/guides/review_criteria_framework.md
  • references/guides/review_panel_provenance_protocol.md
  • references/guides/review_quality_thinking.md
  • references/guides/reviewer_sprint_prompt_source.md
  • references/guides/sprint_contract_protocol.md
  • references/guides/statistical_reporting_standards.md
  • references/guides/top_journals_by_field.md
  • references/methodology_reviewer_agent.md
  • references/perspective_reviewer_agent.md
  • references/shared/authority_content_coverage_advisory_protocol.md
  • references/shared/bibliographic_integrity_signals.md
  • references/shared/claim_strength_ladder.md

Source changelog

Add CC BY-NC 4.0 LICENSE and ATTRIBUTION (based on Academic Research Skills by Cheng-I Wu, https://github.com/Imbad0202/academic-research-skills)